The Best Mattresses of 2024: What the Experts Say

[Updated: AUGUST 1st, 2024]

Do you ever feel stuck when it comes to making new purchases? Keeping up with trends in any industry can be challenging, especially for busy shoppers. It can help to have an insider tip now and then. This is why we made it easier for you by combining customer feedback with our expert knowledge to give you our take on the best mattresses of 2024 and beyond.

What Is the best mattress of 2024? Our overall staff pick is the “Sealy Posturepedic Tight Top Extra Firm Mattress”, but if you are looking for something specific we ranked the best mattress in every popular category: 

If you’re like most people, you probably spend about one-third of your life sleeping. That’s a lot of time, so it’s essential to get the best mattress possible for your needs. A bad mattress can leave you with aches and pains, make it harder to get a good night’s rest, and even lead to long-term back problems.

In this article, we’ll take a look at some of the best mattresses available in 2022. Read on to learn more about these mattresses and which models stand out as the top picks among experts.

 

The Best Budget Mattress (under $500)

Mattressville PROMO Euro Top Mattress

SPECIFICATIONS

Best for: All sleeping positions; side sleepers
Type: Continuous Coil
Firmness: Medium
Warranty: 5 years
Our Price: $349 (Queen) comparable at $649

Pros:

👍Great price
👍Has features found in high-end mattresses
👍Durable edge guard support
👍Aloe vera fabric

Cons:

👎Transfers motion
👎Can feel bouncy
👎Won’t last as long as other mattresses on this list

SHOP→ Classic Euro Top Mattress

---

If you’re shopping on a budget, we have a few suggestions for you. Keep in mind, however, that a cheap mattress will probably end up costing you more in the long run. A low-cost mattress may not last as long as a higher-quality model, and it might not offer the support you need to stay comfortable through the night. Although the saying “you get what you pay for” applies to mattresses as well, there are still some great affordable options that will meet your needs.

One recommendation for a budget-friendly mattress is the Classic Euro Top Mattress. This good old-fashioned coil or innerspring mattress might lack the comfort you are looking for but it does the job. It is a 9-inch mattress made of continuous coils in rows of S-shaped springs formed from single steel wire hinged like offset coils.

It has a small cushion top layer that adds a bit of softness. Medium firmness, good for side sleepers. This mattress is also very budget-friendly, coming in at less than $500 for a full-size model.

 

The Best High-End Mattress

Stearns and Foster Pillow Top Luxury Firm Mattress

 

 

SPECIFICATIONS

Best for: All sleeping positions; side sleepers
Type: Pocket coil; Intellicoil™, PRECISIONMATCH memory foam
Firmness: Medium (luxury firm)
Warranty: 10 years
Our Price: $1949 (Queen) comparable at $3375

Pros:

👍Superior quality
👍Double coil support
👍Luxurious materials such as Silk, Wool, Cashmere
👍AirVent System

Cons:

👎The mattress is very heavy
👎Above average price point

SHOP→ Steans and Foster Pillow Top Luxury Firm Mattress

---

If you want the best of the best, you will probably want to invest in a high-end mattress. These models are typically made with higher-quality materials, which also cost more to produce. A high-end mattress is more likely to last longer and provide a more comfortable sleep surface for years to come.

Stearns & Foster is a brand that is synonymous with quality, and the top recommendation for a high-end mattress is the Stearns and Foster Luxury Firm Pillow Top Mattress. This model is made of only the finest materials, the most exacting standards, and the highest craftsmanship to deliver a superior mattress. Fun fact: it takes twice as long to make as an ordinary mattress.

Its unique Intellicoil core support system delivers double coils that adapt to the size, shape, and weight of any body size. With added comfort layers this mattress will provide the ideal level of support.

 

The Best Memory Foam Mattress

TEMPUR-PEDIC Tempur Align 2.0 Medium Mattress

SPECIFICATIONS

Best for: All sleeping positions
Type: Memory foam; Tempur®
Firmness: Medium
Warranty: 10 years
Our Price: $1949 (Queen) comparable at $4399

Pros:

👍Best pressure relieving material
👍Helps relieve aches and pains for those with joint or bone problems, or who have bad posture.
👍 Cool-To-The-Touch temperature control
👍 motion isolation

Cons:

👎Very Expensive
👎Can take some time to adapt if you are not used to sleeping on memory foam

SHOP→ TEMPUR-PEDIC Tempur Align Medium Mattress

---

If you’re looking for a mattress that boasts strong support, relieves pressure, and provides extra cushioning, then a memory foam mattress may be ideal for you. This mattress type is designed to contour your body and support your joints and muscles, allowing you to stay asleep throughout the night without tossing and turning. Memory foam beds are not just good mattresses for side sleepers, but good for all sleeping positions.

There are so many different memory foam mattress brands claiming to be the best and we understand how overwhelming all these options can be. This category winner is Tempur-Pedic and that should not come as a surprise.

These mattresses were originally based on NASA's research to develop a material that would cushion aircraft seats and ensure survivability in the event of an accident. Tempur-Pedic mattresses are designed to be one of the most comfortable and supportive mattresses you will find. A great choice for a memory foam mattress is the Tempur-Pedic Tempur Align 2.0 Medium Mattress for its viscoelastic, pressure relieving, and temperature-sensitive material giving you the perfect support, comfort, and a superior night's rest.

The Best Mattress For Teenagers

Kingsdown Euro Top Firm Mattress

SPECIFICATIONS

Best for: Back and stomach sleepers
Type: Pocket Coil, Lumber Support
Firmness: Firm
Warranty: 10 years
Our Price: $999 (Queen) comparable at $1699

Pros:

👍Good support and comfort.
👍Cooling Fibers 
👍Moisture-wicking material
👍Less expensive alternative to high-end mattresses with the same features

Cons:

👎No natural latex or organic materials
👎Not an alternative to latex mattresses if looking for natural organic products

SHOP→ Kingsdown Euro Top Firm Mattress

---

If you have a teenager who is transitioning into a bigger bed, you may want to consider an extra-supportive mattress in the mid-price range. Mattresses for teens should provide strong support and last for several years, even as your teen grows. After all, good quality sleep for teenagers is especially important for physical health, emotional and mental development, and school performance. On average your teenager should get around 8 to 10 hours of sleep so they will need a decent mattress to help them rest.

The Kingsdown Euro Top Mattress is a firm mattress constructed with Hotel Quality Pocket Coils that work independently for targeted support of the entire body and reduce motion transfer, while the Micro Gel Foam helps to keep you cool and comfortable. It is good for all sleep positions.

The Best Mattress For Guestroom

Orthopedic Foam Mattress

SPECIFICATIONS

Best for: Back and stomach sleepers
Type: High-density foam
Firmness: Medium
Warranty: 5 years
Our Price: $469 (Queen) comparable at $749

Pros:

👍Supportive and comfortable
👍Zero motion transfer
👍Bamboo quilted fabric

Cons:

👎Won’t last as long as other mattresses on this list

SHOP→ Orthopedic Foam Mattress

---

If you’re shopping for a mattress for a guest bedroom, and think that the best option is probably a no-frills, budget-friendly model — then you are not wrong. A budget-friendly mattress is still a good choice for a guest bedroom as you probably do not want to spend a lot of money on a bed that may get very little use.

You don't want your guests to be too comfortable and stay forever because they fall in love with the guest bed, also you don't want them to be grumpy in the morning and complain.

We overstand, that’s why we recommend the Orthopedic Foam Mattress.
This is a medium firm mattress made of high-density foam and quilted top bamboo fabric. It's designed with a focus on providing the correct support for your body and spine posture. It is good for all sleep positions but recommended for back and stomach sleepers so most of your guests should get a good night's rest (but not too good)

 

The Best Mattress For Large Body Types

Stearns and Foster Tight Top Luxury Firm Mattress

SPECIFICATIONS

Best for: All sleeping positions
Type: Pocket Coil; Intellicoil™, PRECISIONMATCH memory foam
Firmness: Firm (luxury firm)
Warranty: 10 years
Our Price: $1699 (Queen) comparable at $3275

Pros:

👍Intellicoil system provides better support than average pocket coils
👍AirVent System
👍Durable edge support

Cons:

👎The mattress is very heavy
👎Above average price point

SHOP→ Stearns and Foster Tight Top Luxury Firm Mattress

---

If you have a large or extra large body type and are heavy set or weigh more than the average person, you may need a mattress that will provide additional support. The most common issue with mattresses is sagging. It usually happens due to a lack of coils and/or durability of coils to provide sufficient support, or because of poor quality of mattress layers that become easily compressed.

Ideally, you will want a model that can support your body without feeling too soft or too firm. This can help to prevent pain, cramping, and even back problems that may come from sleeping on a mattress that’s too soft.

A good recommendation for heavier sleepers is the Stearns and Foster Tight Top Luxury Firm Mattress. With its unique double (Intellicoil) system and Vented Precision Edge Support, it is the ideal design to provide more support for larger bodies. This robust coil-in-coil system delivers on two levels - one to ensure unmatched support to your body, while the second set of coils works to provide you with a deeper restorative rest.

An innovative system of firmer edge coils provides an improved life span and offers better support. This mattress is a little more expensive than other picks on this list, but it’s also built with higher-quality materials that are likely to last longer.

 

The Best Mattress For A Cooler Sleep

Kingsdown Cool Wave Tight Top Mattress (Coolest Mattress in The World)

SPECIFICATIONS

Best for: All sleeping positions
Type: Memory foam
Firmness: Medium
Warranty: 10 years
Our Price: $1299 (Queen) comparable at $2279

Pros:

👍Great price
👍Regulates body temperature
👍Provides pressure relief
👍14 ventilation channels

Cons:

👎Can take some time to adapt if you are not used to sleeping on memory foam

SHOP→ Kingsdown Coolest Mattress in The World

---

Attention hot sleepers, If you find that you get hot while you sleep, you will definitely benefit from a cooling mattress. A cooling mattress can help to keep you from overheating, especially if you sleep with a partner who brings more body heat to bed. Additionally, some cooling materials even help to absorb or wick away excess moisture during the night.

A very good option for a cooler mattress is the Kingsdown Cool Wave Mattress. Also known as the coolest mattress in the world it is the coolest sleep experience rolled into a box. It is specially designed so air flows freely on the inside to keep you comfortable while you sleep. These boxed mattresses feel cool to the touch.

This mattress is great for people who tend to run on the hotter side and need a cooler sleeping surface. This mattress is very cool (pun intended).

 

The Best Natural/Organic Latex Mattress

Natura Natural Latex Tight Top Medium Firm Mattress

SPECIFICATIONS

Best for: All sleeping positions
Type: Pocket Coil, Natural organic latex
Firmness: Medium Firm
Warranty: 10 years
Our Price: $1249 (Queen) comparable at $2329

Pros:

👍Good for allergy sufferers
👍Durable and biodegradable materials
👍Regulates temperature
👍Reduces bacterial growth

Cons:

👎Very heavy
👎Off-gassing; fresh latex mattresses will initially smell like rubber

SHOP→ Natura Natural Latex Tight Top Medium Firm Mattress

---

If you are looking for a green, organic mattress that’s hypoallergenic, chemical-free and made with natural organic latex, then Natura's Natural Latex Tight Top Medium Firm Mattress is the best choice for you. This top-ranked mattress features 1" of firm latex, 1” Graphite Copper Foam, Luxurious Organic Cotton Quilt, and 22 oz Joma Wool Fibre.

This mattress is antimicrobial and hypoallergenic, so it’s a great choice for allergy sufferers. It also has a very slow-response time, which means it won’t feel too soft when you sit or lie down on it.

 

Staff Pick

Sealy Posturepedic Tight Top Firm Mattress

 

SPECIFICATIONS

Best for: Back and stomach sleepers
Type: Pocket coil; SealyResponse PRO Coils
Firmness: Firm
Warranty: 10 years
Our Price: $899 (Queen) comparable at $1198

Pros:

👍Great price
👍Posturepedic technology
👍Lumbar support
👍Reinforced durable edge

Cons:

👎 Firmness is not suitable for everyone, especially not for side sleepers

SHOP→ Sealy Posturepedic Tight Top Firm Mattress

---

When selecting our staff pick we considered a few factors: our customers' feedback, sales data, what we like, and something that was the average of all the products on this list. This mattress would be none other than the Sealy Posturepedic Tight Top Firm Mattress. This is a great choice for anyone shopping for mattresses for back pain. It will help with aches or pains and has been known to help people with back pain get more restful sleep.

Sealy Posturepedic has worked with orthopedic specialists to create real support so your body can fully relax and sleep well. Sealy’s famous Posturepedic Technology™ targets the heaviest part of your body, with twice as much support where you need it most.

As the top-selling brand in Canada, Sealy is committed to providing quality customer care and being an industry leader in both comfort and support.

 

BONUS: Top Selling Mattress Online 

Stearns and Foster Lux Estate Pillow Top Ultra Plush Mattress 

Discover the Stearns and Foster Estate Collection, a limited-time offering that's soon to be discontinued. Seize the opportunity to own one of our most popular mattresses at exceptional prices, available only while stocks last.

The crown jewel of this collection, the Marcela mattress from the Lux Estate series, stands out as the ultimate choice for those seeking a Stearns and Foster Pillow Top Ultra Plush mattress. It's a dream come true for any sleep position, thanks to its innovative Intellicoil core support system. This system features 1,504 individually wrapped coils, expertly crafted to conform to your body's unique size, shape, and weight, ensuring unparalleled support and effortless movement.

 

How We Selected This List

This list of best mattresses of 2024 was completely independently written by the editors of Mattressville. The contributors to this list are senior employees of Mattressville, with a combined 20 years of mattress manufacturing, testing, and sales experience. This means that this article was written by real industry experts, with real industry experience and product knowledge.

When putting together this guide a lot of things went into consideration including:

• Customer reviews: we pay close attention to what people actually like
• Top sellers: we analyzed sales data to help pick the winner of each category
• Testing: our product experts know exactly what to look for when testing the quality of each product
• Comparison: we compared these products to similar products sold by competitors
• Price: we know people shop by price and we aimed for the best value in each category
• Returns: we factored in which mattresses are returned most often, and excluded those from the list
• Mattress Matchmaker: we have analyzed many years of first-party data from people who have tried our Mattress Matchmaker, the tool which makes it easy to shop for a mattress based on sleeping position, preferred comfort level, body type, and mattress style
• Comfort: comfort should never be compromised so it was a key factor for each category

When you combine all these things, you really get the ultimate list which is not only based on analyzing years of first party data, but also unbiased and written by real industry experts.

How To Choose The Best Mattress

As we mentioned many times in this guide, comfort should never be compromised. You are probably thinking that comfort is personal and subjective -and you are correct. That is why we encourage anyone shopping for a new mattress to try it first. It is always best to visit your local store and try the mattress for a 5-10 minutes and when you are done, come back and try it again.

This process should not be rushed, that's why there are showrooms with rows and rows of mattresses. When you actually physically try them out, you will notice they are not all the same. We encourage our customers to block out all the noise; ignore online reviews, the brand, style, price etc. Just close your eyes and look for your ideal comfort level.

If you cannot visit a store for whatever reason, our Mattress Matchmaker makes it easy to buy a mattress online. We also have live chat support on our website or you can call us to speak to an expert. When buying a new mattress, keep in mind that it will take some time for your body to adjust to your new bed, typically 3-4 weeks known as the "break in" period.

How Long Do Mattresses Last?

Your mattress should typically last between 7-10 years, although Mattressville recommends changing your mattress after no longer than 8 years. You can learn more about how long mattresses last in this article we wrote 7 Signs You Need a Mattress Replacement

You can also get extent the life of your mattress by cleaning it properly and regularly. Sometimes cleaning your mattress can be more headache then its worth, especially if it is heavily stained and/or approaching the 6-8 year mark. For cleaning tips make sure to read How to Clean a Mattress: A Complete Guide

Helpful Resources

• Memory Foam vs Pocket Coil Mattress: Which Is Right for You?
• Choosing a Mattress Based on Your Sleep Position: What to Know
• How Much Sleep Do We Really Need? Your Essential Sleep Guide
• Sleep and Mental Health: What You Need to Know
• Can Buying a New Mattress Improve Your Quality of Life?
• Why Adjustable Beds Aren’t Only for the Elderly

Conclusion

When you are shopping for a new mattress, it’s important to know what to look for. Quality materials like memory foam, pocket coils, or hybrid mattresses are important, but so is finding a mattress that’s the right level of comfort. Choose a firm mattress if you like a little extra support or if you’re heavier. Choose a softer mattress if you like to sink into the bed or if you’re lighter.

Since we are all so different, is there really such a thing as the absolute best mattress? We will let you decide. The mattress industry is always changing and innovations in materials and designs are always coming out. One thing that remains constant is comfort over everything. Be especially cautious of mattress review sites and “best mattress” lists. Most of the time these are biased, sponsored reviews.

At Mattressville we have no incentive to sell one mattress brand over the other as our objective is to make sure our customers get the best sleep possible. If you would like to learn more about what not to do when shopping for a mattress, continue reading our blog, “10 Common Mattress Shopping Mistakes and How to Avoid Them”.

Try the Mattress Matchmaker by Mattressville, it is our easy-to-use mattress selector designed to help find the best mattress for you or you are welcome to visit us in Mississauga near Toronto. Either way, you can trust Mattressville to help you have a good night, every night!