[Updated Feb 1st, 2025]
The advent of e-commerce has dramatically transformed how we shop, including for items like mattresses. Remember the days when the only way to buy a mattress meant weekend trips to various stores, lying on display pieces under the scrutinizing eyes of salespeople and fellow shoppers? While the experience of feeling a mattress's firmness still has its allure, the digital realm beckons with its convenience and wide range of options.
Today, the convenience of online mattress buying is challenging the traditional approach of buying a mattress in-store. With the industry shifting towards digital platforms, it's essential to understand the pros and cons of these two shopping methods.
Which is the better option? As you grapple with the "click or brick" conundrum, this article explores the nuances of both worlds, offering valuable mattress shopping tips to guide you through this essential purchase. Whether you're a traditionalist or an e-commerce enthusiast, the changing face of mattress shopping is bound to intrigue you.
TL;DR Mattress Shopping, Online Convenience vs. In-Store Confidence?
The rise of e-commerce has transformed mattress shopping, with online purchases offering affordability because of lower overhead costs and frequent promotions. However, in-store shopping provides an immediate hands-on experience.
Online brands usually have extended trial periods and easy return policies, while in-store purchases may come with steeper return fees. The best way to buy a mattress depends on individual preference. Online shopping offers convenience, cost-effectiveness, and a wide selection. In-store shopping is still a sure way to find your ideal comfort by physically trying the bed.
Overview
The Changing Face of Mattress Shopping
Navigating the world of mattress shopping can feel like a puzzle. Do you click and buy online or visit a store to try before you buy? Which type of mattress is right for you? Both methods have their own set of perks.
With online shopping booming, many turn to the internet to find their perfect mattress. But others still enjoy the trust they get from seeing a mattress in person.
The pandemic-induced shift toward online shopping has significantly influenced consumer behaviour. No longer are people lining up at stores and spending days circling shopping centres. A lot of consumers have not only switched some of their shopping to online retailers but have done away with physical stores altogether.
The mattress industry is no exception to this trend. While the allure of trying out a mattress in a physical store remains, online mattress brands are gaining momentum for their affordability, convenience, and extensive range.
Comparing In-Store and Online Mattress Shopping
Affordability: A Key Consideration
Shopping Online: A Pocket-Friendly Option
One of the most significant advantages of online mattress shopping is its affordability. Online mattresses are typically more affordable than their in-store counterparts because of the absence of overhead costs like rent and staff salaries. Online retailers pass these savings on to the customers, offering high-quality mattresses at more competitive prices.
The online market offers an extensive price range, catering to various budgets. From budget-friendly beds to luxury, high-end options, the online world is your oyster. Moreover, online mattress brands frequently offer discounts and promotions, especially during the holiday season making them a cost-effective choice.
However, one potential drawback is the inability to physically test the mattress before purchase. To mitigate this risk, many online brands offer generous trial periods, allowing you to test the mattress at home and return it if unsatisfied, often without any added return fees. Furthermore, some brands offer bundled deals, including accessories or additional products with the mattress, adding more value to your purchase.
Buying In Store: A Limited Affordability Scope
When considering affordability in physical stores, the price variability is generally less diverse compared to online shopping. The simple reason is that a physical store can only hold a limited number of mattress types, chosen at the discretion of the store owner. Nevertheless, you can be assured that the money you're spending is worth it since you can try out the bed before you buy. But remember, a quick in-store test doesn't truly compare to the experience of a full night's sleep.
Quality and Trust: Evaluating Your Options
Online Shopping: High Quality at Your Fingertips
The quality of online mattresses may surprise you. Renowned brands have made their mark in the industry by offering high-quality mattresses made with top-notch materials. It's essential, however, to do your research and review the construction specifications listed on the brand's website. Look for details about foam density and special technologies to ensure you're getting your money's worth.
The quality of a mattress depends on its construction, materials, and durability, not on where it's sold. Many online mattress brands offer high-quality products comparable to, and sometimes even better than, those sold in stores.
It is always a good idea to make a list of what you are looking for in a mattress before beginning your online shopping. Once you have your list, you want to take notes based on your research and categorize top to low priority. For example, if spinal alignment is something you currently have issues with, you want to prioritize mattresses that can aid with that part of your sleep.
Once you have your list, check out the online retailers you trust and narrow them down based on price, location (the closer to you, the faster the shipping will be,) and general customer reviews.
Shopping In-Store: The Traditional Route
While shopping in-store, the quality of mattresses is quite high as the store owners usually showcase their best products. However, you rely on the salesperson to provide you with information about the mattress's construction, which may not always be as detailed as the information available online. On the other hand, the opportunity to try out a mattress in person can be a more reliable indicator of its quality.
Trial Periods: A Crucial Factor
Online Brands: Long Trial Periods
Most online brands offer generous trial periods, allowing customers to test the mattress for an extended period, often up to 100 nights, before making a final decision. This "buy-before-you-try" model may seem risky to some, but it's an effective way to truly understand if the mattress suits your needs.
It might seem daunting to have to return a mattress you bought online, but mattress returns are no different from any other product. Each store will have their process, though most will try to accommodate you and your needs as best as they can.
In-Store Shopping: Limited Trial Experience
In-store shopping allows you to try out as many beds as you like, helping you narrow down the feel that's right for you. However, a quick tryout in-store doesn't truly compare to sleeping on the mattress for several nights. This is where online-only trial periods may prove to be a more significant advantage.
Customer Service: Finding the Right Balance
Online Shopping: Hassle-Free Customer Service
Online mattress brands typically offer excellent customer service, with brand experts available via chat portals to answer your queries. You can browse at your own pace without the pressure of a salesperson trying to upsell you.
With a lot of people preferring to deal with customer service via chat to avoid spending time glued to a phone, online mattress shopping could be the solution. It will allow you to get all the information you need without stepping foot in a physical store.
In-Store Shopping: Face-to-Face Interaction
While in-store shopping may involve dealing with sometimes pushy salespeople, some shoppers prefer real-time interaction and the opportunity to ask questions on the spot. If you enjoy negotiating and discussing your options with a professional, in-store shopping might be a better choice for you.
In-store shopping will also allow you to bring other people with you to try out a mattress, especially if you are not the only one who will be sleeping in the same bed. With that, shopping for a mattress in-store becomes a great solution if you are trying to pick out a bed for a child or teenager.
Delivery: Bringing Your Mattress Home
Online Delivery: Your Mattress at Your Doorstep
One of the primary advantages of online shopping is home delivery. Most online mattress brands deliver your mattress right to your front door, often in a conveniently compressed box. Some even offer white glove delivery services, where a company representative sets up the mattress for you.
In-Store Delivery: Quick and Easy
In-store purchases usually come with quick and easy delivery, often on the same or next day. Retailers generally provide movers who will deliver the bed, set it up, and remove your old bed, making the process convenient and hassle-free.
Returns: A Fair Policy is Essential
Online Returns: Simple and Easy
Depending on the brand's policy, returning an online purchase can be easy. Many companies streamline the process for consumers, offering free pick-ups and partnering with local charities to donate unwanted mattresses.
Most online mattress brands have straightforward return policies. If you're not satisfied with your purchase, you can usually arrange for the mattress to be picked up and returned free of charge. However, it's crucial to read the fine print regarding returns before making a purchase.
In-Store Returns: Easier but Costlier
In-store returns are typically easier as the retailer will likely arrange for the mattress to be picked up. However, the return fees associated with in-store purchases can be steep, making the process costlier.
It is always recommended to make sure you select the correct mattress for you and doing a little bit of research and speaking with a sales professional can help narrow it down.
How To Buy a Mattress Online
When you decide to purchase your mattress online, having a clear roadmap can make the process smoother and more confident. Follow these steps to ensure you make an informed decision:
-
Research and Compare Options:
Start by exploring various brands and models. Use filters on our Mattress In A Box Collection to compare features like firmness, materials, and trial periods. Look at expert reviews and customer feedback to narrow down your choices. -
Check Sizing and Specifications:
Before making a purchase, measure your bed frame and room space accurately. Refer to our Mattress Buying Guide for tips on selecting the right size for your sleep needs. -
Review Return Policies and Warranty Information:
Online mattress purchases often come with trial periods. Ensure you understand the return process and warranty details. This step is crucial to protect your investment if the mattress doesn’t meet your expectations.
Tips for a Success
-
Leverage Customer Reviews:
Look for detailed customer reviews that highlight long-term satisfaction or issues. This firsthand feedback can be invaluable in verifying product quality. -
Verify Measurements and Return Policies:
Double-check product dimensions and understand the trial period before committing. -
Look for Promotions and Financing Options:
Many online retailers offer seasonal deals or financing plans. Keep an eye on these offers to maximize your value without compromising on quality. -
Understand the Shipping Process:
Ensure that the mattress will be delivered securely and ask about setup services if needed. This is particularly important if you’re new to the mattress-in-a-box experience. -
Monitor the Trial Period:
Take full advantage of the trial period to assess comfort and support. Remember, adjustments like adding a mattress topper or revisiting your room layout can enhance your sleep even further. -
Maintain Your Mattress:
For long-term performance, refer to our Mattress Care & Maintenance Guide for tips on cleaning and care.
Online vs. In-Store: The Verdict
Both in-store and online mattress shopping have their advantages and disadvantages. While in-store shopping allows for a more hands-on approach, online shopping offers a wider selection, more competitive prices, and the convenience of shopping from the comfort of your home. The best way to buy a mattress ultimately depends on your personal preferences and needs.
Wrapping Up
Making the right choice between buying a mattress online or in a store can be frustrating, and it is ultimately up to what you feel is most comfortable and supportive. We've seen how e-commerce has reshaped the way we pick out the perfect bed. From the ease and cost-effectiveness of clicking and ordering a bed in a box online, to the trust and hands-on experience of selecting a mattress in-store, there's a lot to consider.
The clear benefits of online shopping — such as variety, affordability, and unmatched convenience — are drawing more and more folks to the digital realm. We still encourage folks to stop by your local mattress store and physically try a mattress as it is the sure-shot way to find your best comfort fit.
Whatever you choose, being well-informed will ensure you pick the best mattress for your needs. We hope that this helps make your mattress-buying journey a smooth and successful one. Happy shopping!
FAQ
Q. Is it better to buy a mattress online or in a store?
A. The "better" option depends on your personal preference. Buying online offers convenience, potentially lower prices, and a broader selection. You might also benefit from extended trial periods that let you test the mattress at home. On the other hand, buying in-store allows you to feel the mattress firsthand and get immediate answers to questions. It’s essential to weigh the importance of hands-on experience against the convenience and range of online shopping.
Q. How can I trust the quality of a mattress if I buy it online without trying it first?
A. Many online mattress companies provide detailed product descriptions, customer reviews, and extensive trial periods, sometimes up to 100 nights or more. This allows you to test the mattress in the comfort of your home. Doing thorough research, reading reviews, and understanding the return policy can help alleviate concerns about quality and comfort.
Q. Are online mattress trial periods genuinely risk-free? What's the catch?
A. Most online mattress brands offer generous risk-free trial periods. The primary catch is ensuring you understand the return policy. While many companies offer free returns and full refunds, some might have specific conditions or restocking fees. Always read the fine print before making a purchase.
Q. If I buy a mattress in-store, can I still get it delivered to my home?
A. Yes, many brick-and-mortar mattress stores offer home delivery services. Some even provide same-day or next-day delivery, and they might offer to set up the new mattress and remove the old one. However, delivery fees can vary, so it's best to confirm the details with the retailer.
Q. Are mattresses purchased online of the same quality as those in retail stores?
A. The quality of a mattress is determined by its construction, materials, and manufacturing processes, not by where it's sold. There are high-quality options available both online and in-store. Some mattress-in-a-box products are gimmicky and overpriced. As always, research, reading reviews, and understanding the product specifications are key to determining a mattress's quality, whether you're shopping online or in a brick-and-mortar store.
Q. I don't like memory foam, do roll-packed mattresses come in different styles?
A. Mattresses in a box are available in other styles than memory foam mattresses. These can be soft or firm mattresses, pocket coil, as well as latex mattresses and hybrid mattresses.
